The camera never lies, huh? Then mine’s the exception that proves the rule.
See these kids? See this homemade craft class? Idyllic, right? WRONG. Wrong, wrong, wrong.
It was cold. The day was stretching out empty in front of us. We were cocky. My friend had an amazing idea: a dinosaur hunt.
We’d make dinosaurs out of old cereal packets and the kids would decorate them with left over wrapping paper. Then we’d make ‘dinosaur eggs’ (cornflake cakes), the kids would stir the mix and dollop bits into an egg box before we left them to set.
Then, in the afternoon, we’d hide the cardboard dinosaurs around the local park and when the kids found them, they could trade them in for a dinosaur egg.
It was, I still maintain, an INSPIRED idea. So many different activities, lots of different skills, shed loads of fun, bit of time inside, bit of time outside… What could go wrong?
Well maybe I don’t need to tell you. Because maybe you’re one of the many amazing women I’ve met during the last fortnight who whip up creative, thrifty fun all the time (I’m working on a database of these heroines for the blog, by the way). Or maybe you’d just never be daft enough to try and do this all yourself. Either way: kudos.
Because let me tell you, it was BLOODY exhausting. Any idea how much time was spent with the kids actually engaged in the activity we’d designed versus the amount of time we put into planning and tidying up? Well, I can’t tell you. Because I was too busy flinging myself around to tot it up. But I’d estimate about 5:1 – five parts prep and tidy to one part engaged kids.
Don’t get me wrong: the kids LOVED sitting at the table and decorating. For five minutes. And they loved stirring the mixture. Maybe for sixty seconds. And they would have loved the dinosaur hunt, if it hadn’t been so cold that our noses were at critical risk from frostbite.
And all the time, I was thinking: if I’d paid £2.50 to go to the toy library, I could have saved myself a whole lot of bloody bother.
Actually, this is one of the things I feel most ambivalent about stopping (along with shopping for second hand things and supporting charity shops – more on this later).
Not the soft-play centres or expensive classes, but the great local playgroups and toy libraries that charge to attend, but not a fortune. And they do such a great job. They bring communities together and (I cannot stress this enough) they clear up the crap that you and your gorgeous progeny leave your in wake.
For us, our project relies entirely on the huge crowd of friends Johnny has of his own age. We can have them round for activities, head out to museums and woods with them. If we didn’t have that circle – if none of my friends had had kids at roughly the same time, or I lived in a less friendly neighbourhood – I’m not sure cutting back on ‘paid-for’ activities would be doable.
Kids need company and parents have a human right to get together to trade horror stories. Local play centres and their ilk go on valiently providing all that and more despite dire financial straits. In fact, I wouldn’t have met the kids in these pictures if I hadn’t been going to the local toy library last year.
But look, it wasn’t a total failure. It was a great, erm… experience. I learnt a lot and parts of it were a grand success. Bits of it were great fun for all of us: kids and adults. I think, (although my memory of the whole thing is hazy) that those parts were more fun that the average playgroup.
Oh, and if I had a cleaner, I’d be well up for doing the whole thing again. Or, since that’s already in the realm of total fantasy, an extra six hours in every day, a warmer climate and a topless man servant (What? It couldn’t hurt morale, could it?)
[Eagle eyed readers will spot the suspicious juice bottle in J's hand in the pic above. It's filled with tap water! I promise!]






Firstly, hahahahahaaaaaa.
Of course it will be carnage. Stuff like this is always carnage! I can only do baking etc activities with stan if I’ve weighed and laid out everything ready to fling into a bowl while he’s having his nap. Then we are ok. Otherwise don’t even think about trying to weigh anything out for that recipe…it is all guesswork!
Also I agree on supporting locally funded things like libraries, toy libraries etc and some other activities where children get to interact with other children and other adults. I think it is important to support things like that. As an author/illustrator I go to give workshops and visits as part of my income and it is nice when lots of children and parents turn up – even if it has cost them a few quid – it is something different to do. I think with many of your rules you can be careful about who and what you buy/support rather than going totally cold turkey….
Sx
To use J’s favourite phrase, “It’s tricky isn’t it?”
The idea of saying point-blank “no” to spending on everything at the very start is that it should prompt me to scrutinise exactly where our money’s going and whether those are good places for it to be going to (financially, ethically and all the other ‘ally’s…)
In lots of cases, I was just spending without thinking (which is unbelievably dumb for someone who’s pretty broke!)
In this case, it’s made me think about the real value of that locally funded stuff. Which I hadn’t, deeply, before. So in that sense, at least, it’s been really useful.
Yep, not a tooooootal disaster…
Of course. You need to get rid of it all and then slowly introduce. It is a good plan. I don’t think it’s dumb to keep spending on the kids, it is what it seems everyone is doing and what is the ‘right’ thing to do. Plus it becomes habit. You did it/bought it last last week why the heck wouldn’t you this week?!
In fact without this blog even though I thought about my spending every now and then I didn’t really think about it properly. It’s been great, I’ve started to re-address what I buy again and where….
I have just discovered your website and am enjoying it a lot, esp this post. I have to say, I laughed. A lot. As a mother of 4 older children I remember the days, when as an idealistic young parent I did this sort of thing too. Then one day I realised that toddlers don’t ‘get’ craft. They like making a big mess, and hurtling around with their friends/mortal enemies, whatever it might be that day. So by child No.4 we did finger painting in the bath, and ‘craft’ with glitter and glue when grandma was in charge.
Don’t get me wrong, that activity would have been so much fun for 5 or 6 yr olds, but you will collapse with exhaustion if you waste all that creativity on toddlers.
Good luck with your brilliant project, and be kind to yourself!
Hi Hattie,
This looks like the activity you should exuberantly suggest when playtime is at someone elses house! Well done on the creativity and energy. Plus it’s all documented here for J to see one day and understand what a thoughtful and aware mum he has. Will you ever be able to order a guilt-free skinny latte again?!
Not sure if you have covered the topic of birthdays but being that T has his first one coming up (wow), I have been thinking about what restrictions I can apply to people buying him presents (no speaking toys with annoying accents etc etc). Its not to be a killjoy but because I have seen what my nephew gets each year (he’s 6 now) and its a depressingly huge amount of Made in China junk. He barely looks at half of it!
Made me wonder what you plan to do at birthday time.
All the best from Oz xx
We used to go to the free toddler story time at our local public library – it was free. Also some of them have toys and DVDs which are loaned for free. Not sure if they have them in your area though.
Best piece of advice I’ve been given – kids need nothing more than wax crayons. The only thing I can cope with outside of that is pouring a bag of rice into a washing up bowl and letting them chuck it around with other plastic containers. They love it, I want to do vodka shots.
You could try spreading your ideas out. Like one day make the dinosaur, two days later do a dino hunt (sounds like fun), next day do a special bake day. Trying to do so much always sounds good on paper but rarely goes as planned with little ones.
Hello all you wise, right thinking people! Yeah, spreading this lot out over a couple of days would be much less testing for the mamas and also, I have to get a little less ambitious and more realistic. For some reason (like the pressure to spend?) I seem to fall prey to this silly idea that being a ‘good parent’ (and what the hell is that, anway?!) means getting the boy engaged in ‘constructive’ stuff. In future, more wax crayons, more bathtime mess, more anarchy, less pressure. Oh,and definitely more libraries!
Could you set up your own toy library / book swap among friends? I’ve often thought a book swap would be a great idea, as we have accumulated sooooo many books but new books always pounced on.
Once your son turns three, it’s fun to do junk modelling to make the toy of their choice, and they tend to stay engaged for longer than they do if I decide what to make. You want a dragon, breathing fire, in a castle? Recycling box + sellotape = dragon of your choice. But are you allow to buy sellotape purely for junk modelling as part of your rules?
Oh bless you. It all looks wonderful …. Lucky children! With you on the work / fun ratio tho. I still feel totally gutted when I set up an activity that R engages in for oh, 3 mins, before rushing off to chase the cat or
Something!!
Sigh x
This made me laugh – and then want to cry. Oh those idyllic crafty ideas involving (I shudder to write it) ‘glue’. And then even worse ‘glitter’. And then while you clear up, the kids spread lego and buscuit crumb debris quicker than you can say ‘go and watch Cbeebies. I think I may be scarred.
Love your blog. I thought Americans were the only ones with entirely too much “stuff” in their lives. Totally love your idea. Will be following you with much laughter I am sure.
What are these magicial things called toy libraries or soft-play centers???? I want some!! We live in midwestern America, in a state shaped like a mitten, which is appropriate since nearly half of the year we spend in snow. The only place we have to take the children during these 4/5 months is the library (which gets boring after the 500th time) and Chuck E Cheese. And seeing that I’m on my 3rd child, and have been doing this parenting thing for over 10 years, I am NOT doing Chuck E Cheese ANYMORE! So the idea of toy libraries (HOW does that work??) and soft play centers sounds like heaven to me. (and yes, I did sigh when I wrote that)
What a great idea – but I agree, better for older kids. You and your friend obviously put so much work in, those dinosaurs are beautiful. But totally unappreciated by a bunch of 2 yr olds! Suggest that next time you simplify things a bit. Instead of spending an hour cutting out the dinosaurs, just give them a drawing of a dinosaur on cardboard. Lose the liquid glue, give them glue sticks. If glue causes too much anxiety (for you, not them), they LOVE stickers (you may have to peel them off for them at this age – lack of manual dexterity) and crayons (or pencils – easier to clean off anything they draw on “by accident”) are perfectly acceptable to them, and SO much easier to clean up when they get bored 5 minutes later!
Don’t put so much pressure on yourself. How many times have you heard the “we bought him the latest greatest whatever and he played with the box” anecdote? Mothers these days seem to have this huge competitive drive about everything. In wanting our kids to have everything, do everything and not miss out on anything, we are putting too much pressure on ourselves and them. We have a need for there to be a point, to have an end product. You could have just give them paper and glue and they would have had a great time (and made an even bigger mess!) At 2, it is the doing that is more fun for them, rather than the end result.
But don’t lose heart, he will ‘get’ craft eventually. Still waiting for my 5, almost 6, yr old son to. And it is great for their fine motor control.
Good luck with your experiment. It is amazing how little kids actually need when you get down to it, as opposed to what society (or advertisers) tell us they do.
Cheers (also from Oz).
Oh I remember it well!! mine are all grown up now but they all remember the messy baking activities much more than the expensive presents. My daughter still tells her friends about the time she was ‘helping’ mix ingredients so enthusiastically that the mixture ended up on the ceiling!! and she is 19 , my son remembers helping his Dad in the shed and using real tools that when he went to school and was shown a toy hammer he told the teacher it couldnt be a hammer because it was red!
Good Luck with this, getting back to basics, spending time with a child, looking at things through a childs eyes ….is all so important, they will have good strong relationships, feel valued and have happy memories!
nice idea … Regards